Georgia Real Estate Counteroffers: Best Practices for Cleaner Contracts and Fewer Last-Minute Surprises
- Melissa Gilbert
- 5 days ago
- 5 min read
A counteroffer can be a simple way to negotiate a handful of terms without rewriting an entire offer. But once a transaction gets closer to closing, that same simplicity can sometimes create confusion for clients, lenders and others trying to review the final agreement.
We've recently seen lenders ask for additional signatures on the Purchase and Sale Agreement or financing exhibit as a final underwriting condition, sometimes only a few days before closing.
That can create an awkward conversation when the terms shown on those unsigned documents are no longer the terms the parties actually agreed to.
How the GAR Counteroffer Works
GAR F249, Counteroffer to or Modification of the Unaccepted Original Offer, is designed to work together with the original offer.
The form establishes several important things:
Previous counteroffers are rejected and do not become part of the final agreement.
The original offer, including its exhibits, is incorporated into the accepted counteroffer.
If something in the counteroffer conflicts with the original offer, the counteroffer controls.
Terms that aren't changed by the counteroffer remain as they were written in the original offer.
The counteroffer itself can create the binding agreement even if the incorporated Purchase and Sale Agreement or exhibits were not separately signed or initialed.
That last point is where we sometimes see a practical issue later in the transaction.
When an Underwriting Request Creates Client Confusion
Let's say a buyer originally offers:
Purchase Price: $500,000
Financing Contingency: 15 days
The seller counters using F249 and the parties ultimately agree to:
Purchase Price: $510,000
Financing Contingency: 12 days
The accepted counteroffer controls those terms.
The buyer already signed the original Purchase and Sale Agreement and financing exhibit when making the offer. The seller did not.
Now imagine that two days before closing, the lender asks for the seller's signatures on the original Purchase and Sale Agreement and Conventional Loan Contingency Exhibit.
From the seller's perspective, they're suddenly being asked to sign a contract showing that they're selling their house for $500,000 when they actually negotiated and agreed to $510,000.
That's understandably confusing.
An agent who understands the contract knows the counteroffer controls and the $510,000 purchase price hasn't changed. But the seller may reasonably wonder why they're being asked, at the last minute, to sign something that appears to say otherwise.
And two days before closing is not an ideal time to create unnecessary uncertainty about what a client actually agreed to.
Think About the Entire Contract Package
There isn't one negotiation method that's right for every transaction. But it helps to think beyond getting the counteroffer signed and consider how easy the final contract package will be for someone else to understand later.
Here are a few options agents may want to discuss with their broker.
1. Keep the Counteroffer and Original Documents Together
If additional signatures are requested later, consider providing the seller with the accepted counteroffer, original Purchase and Sale Agreement and applicable exhibits together.
That gives the seller the full context before being asked to sign a document containing a term that was later modified.
A simple explanation can help:
"The counteroffer you already signed still controls the terms we negotiated. The lender is requesting additional signatures on the documents that were incorporated into that agreement."
2. Consider a Conformed or "Clean" Copy
F249 specifically provides a procedure for creating a conformed or clean copy of the agreement that combines the original offer with the controlling terms of the counteroffer.
The form also references SS622, Conformed Copy of Agreement, for this purpose.
From a document-management standpoint, this can make the final agreement much easier for clients and third parties to read because the controlling terms appear together rather than requiring someone to move back and forth between documents.
Always follow your broker's instructions when preparing a conformed copy.
3. Consider Whether a Revised Offer Makes More Sense
Sometimes the cleanest negotiation is simply a revised offer.
If several terms need to change, the parties and their agents may decide that revising and resubmitting the offer is easier to follow than layering multiple changes into a counteroffer.
There are pros and cons to both approaches. Counteroffers can be efficient and provide a clear record of the negotiation. Revised offers can sometimes create a cleaner final package.
Y
our broker can help determine which approach best fits your transaction and brokerage practices.
4. Follow Broker or Closing Attorney Guidance on Additional Corrections
In some transactions, a broker or closing attorney may recommend making superseded terms visually consistent before obtaining additional signatures, such as striking through an old term, replacing it with the controlling term and having the appropriate parties initial the change.
Because this involves modifying the face of a contract document, agents should follow the direction of their broker and, when appropriate, the closing attorney rather than creating their own procedure.
The Other Counteroffer Trap: What You Don't Change Still Matters
One of the easiest things to overlook when completing a counteroffer is that you aren't creating a brand-new agreement.
The original offer is still there.
If the counteroffer doesn't change a particular term, that term generally remains as written in the original offer.
This becomes especially important when there are multiple special stipulations.
We've seen transactions where the buyer, seller and agents all believed they had reached the same agreement, but a careful reading of the original special stipulations together with the counteroffer produced a different result.
No one was trying to make a mistake. Everyone was focused on the terms actively being negotiated.
The problem was a term that wasn't being discussed anymore.
A Simple Counteroffer Double-Check
Before sending a counteroffer for signatures, take one more pass through the entire original offer.
Ask yourself:
Which terms are we intentionally changing?
Which original terms will remain unchanged?
Are there special stipulations that are affected by the new terms?
Do any exhibits contain information that now conflicts with the counteroffer?
If someone unfamiliar with the negotiation reads the entire contract package later, will they understand what the parties ultimately agreed to?
That last question is particularly helpful.
The contract doesn't stop being used once binding agreement happens. Buyers, sellers, agents, transaction coordinators, lenders and closing attorneys may all need to rely on it throughout the transaction.
A few extra minutes making sure the final agreement tells the story clearly can save a lot of explaining when everyone is trying to get to the closing table.
This article is intended for educational purposes and is not legal advice. Agents should always follow their broker's policies and consult their broker or closing attorney when questions arise about completing, modifying or signing contract documents.
← Back to the August Agent Update
Read the next article →
Comments